Something has shifted at Southampton. The anger is still there. The hurt runs deep. But when SaintsExtra ran a poll asking supporters whether Tonda Eckert should stay or go, the result was not what many expected.
Eight out of ten Southampton fans who took part in the poll voted to keep him.
The latest @SaintsWeb poll on the future of Tonda Eckert at #SaintsFC 📊 pic.twitter.com/e7ylxg5JSu
— SaintsExtra (@SaintsExtra) May 26, 2026
That is not a small majority. That is a fanbase that has looked at the full picture and made a clear call.
Spygate was a disaster, and the punishment was severe. But the supporters who watch this team every week have separated the manager from the scandal in a way that many outside the club have refused to do.
What the numbers say
Despite the sample size of the vote, the poll result did not come out of nowhere. Eckert took Southampton from 21st place in the Championship to fourth. He oversaw a 19-game unbeaten run. He reached an FA Cup semi-final, losing only to eventual winners Manchester City.
Those are facts. They do not disappear because of what happened in May.
The supporters who voted to keep Eckert remembered all of that. They saw a manager who transformed a struggling squad and built something genuine at St Mary's.
They are not naive about what happened. They simply believe the good outweighs the bad and that rebuilding with Eckert gives Southampton a better chance than starting from scratch.
That view deserves some respect. It is not blind loyalty. It is an informed judgment from people who watched every game this season.
A fanbase less divided than the headlines suggest
Earlier this week the picture looked far more complicated. Reports suggested the dressing room was split and the fanbase divided. The poll tells a different story.
Eight in ten is a strong mandate. It shows that while some supporters remain hurt and angry, the overwhelming view is that Southampton should back their manager and push for promotion next season.
Some fans have drawn comparisons to Leeds United, who kept Marcelo Bielsa after their own spygate scandal in 2019 and earned promotion the following year. Bielsa still has hero status at Elland Road. Whether Eckert can follow a similar path remains to be seen.
The comments from Southampton fans underneath the SaintsExtra post generally reflected the mood. Fans acknowledged the mistake, accepted the punishment and moved on. Most simply want to go again next season with a manager who knows the club, knows the players and knows how to win.
That is a reasonable position. If, as suggested by the poll suggests, 80 per cent of fans do want him to stay, Sport Republic would do well to listen.
The board now has a clear signal from a small sample of the people who buy the tickets, travel to away games and sing in the stands every week. The fanbase has made its feelings known.
But there is one voice that has not yet spoken. The FA investigation remains ongoing and individual bans are still a real possibility. If Eckert is handed a significant touchline ban, the decision gets taken completely out of Southampton's hands.
The FA may yet have the final word.
Add us as a preferred source on Google